Category: Uncategorized
-

Champion’s Latest Engine Appeal in Art Unit 3747
“Mounted” versus “connected” seems to make a difference in claim scope under the BRI.
-

Detecting Document Annotation Errors = Not Abstract
The PTAB confirms patentability under Section 101 of document segmentation for annotation error identification.
-

Classifiers are Merely Abstract Ideas
“The US doesn’t really need people to study computer science” – that is what the the USPTO is saying every day.
-

When Examiners use Restrictions for Rejections
Restrictions used as a basis for downstream rejections.
-

When Examiners Rely on Non-analogous Art
Learn how to set up arguments to disqualify prior art as non-analogous to overcome obviousness rejections.
-

-

-

More Reversals in Art Unit 3747
As discussed in previous posts (here, here, here, here, here, here), there are some pockets in the USPTO where some fundamental problems persist, forcing applicants into unnecessary appeals. Today we review two new decision from August in Art Unit 3747, one from Honda and one from GM. In each case, the applicant pointed out clear…
-

Obviousness, Hindsight, and Boilerplate
See how examiners user boilerplate to respond to hindsight attacks, and how to re-focus the issue.
-

Patenting Examiner Statistics?
The PTAB says NO to patenting examiner statistics, but not for the reason you might think.