Cheese IP and Overlapping Ranges

Cheese IP and Overlapping Ranges

Sometimes an examiner can show that a claimed feature is inherently provided by prior art that uses the same ranges as disclosed by the applicant. However, just because a range looks to be overlapping because of the values, make sure that what the values represent is really the same parameter. Read a case here about how Wisconsin was able to win protection for their cheese IP because the prior art disclosed a range of a slightly different parameter.